To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.admin.generalOpen lugnet.admin.general in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 Administrative / General / 826
825  |  827
Subject: 
Re: Informal CFD: robotics competition newsgroup(s)
Newsgroups: 
lugnet.admin.general
Date: 
Fri, 15 Jan 1999 02:14:24 GMT
Viewed: 
1785 times
  
I vote for

lugnet.robotics.combat, or
lugnet.robotics.competition

-Chris


Todd Lehman wrote in message <369c1812.15095486@lugnet.com>...

This is an informal call for discussion regarding the creation of a focused
newsgroup/mailing-list for _Robot_Arena_ combat events.  The LEGO • Mindstorms
Robot Arena homepage (not sponsored by The LEGO Group) is located at:

  http://www.azimuthmedia.com/RobotArena/

and takes place in San Jose in March.  Spin-off competitions are being
organized in places such as Los Angeles, Austin, Sarasota FL, and the UK.

Nate Burgess, Robot Arena creator and organizer of the San Jose event, and
David Chen, organizer of the Los Angeles event, are excited about having a
dedicated newsgroup for this; so this is not a CFD on whether to create a
new newsgroup, but on what to call it.

However, it is also a CFD on whether to create a more general sibling-group
for "milder" (i.e., non-combat) competitions in addition to a Robot
Arena-specific newsgroup.  For example, a robotics league in Sarasota,
Florida holds a LEGO Mindstorms "Rug Runners" Competition...

  http://www.pompano.net/~stjohn/contents/GCRL.html

...with other school-sponsored competitions in other cities becoming
increasingly likely.


Some possibilities for names are:

  lugnet.robotics.arena
  lugnet.robotics.robot-arena
  lugnet.robotics.combat
  lugnet.robotics.combat.arena
  lugnet.robotics.compete
  lugnet.robotics.compete.arena
  lugnet.robotics.compete.combat
  lugnet.robotics.compete.general
  lugnet.robotics.competition
  lugnet.robotics.competitions

And some possible charters:

  if Robot Arena-specific:
     The Robot Arena Tournament (a fan-created combat event based on the
     LEGO MINDSTORMS™ RIS):  Discussions, planning, collaboration,
     advocacy, etc.

  if combat-specific:
     Combatant (destructive, gory) events using the LEGO robotics
     components (for example the LEGO MINDSTORMS™ RIS):  Discussions,
     planning, collaboration, advocacy, etc.

  if generic "PG" events:
     General non-combatant competitive events using the LEGO robotics
     components (for example the LEGO MINDSTORMS™ RIS):  Discussions,
     planning, collaboration, advocacy, etc.

Nate Burgess suggests  lugnet.robotics.robot-arena  for all combat-related
LEGO, and  lugnet.robotics.competitions  for non-combatant tourneys
(especially K-12 school-sponsored).

David Chen concurs but suggests lugnet.robotics.competition (singular • rather
than plural) for the less-gory affairs.

--Todd

p.s.  This message is crossposted to lugnet.admin.general & • lugnet.robotics,
with followups set to lugnet.admin.general.  After the group (or groups) • are
created, a note will be posted to lugnet.announce and lugnet.robotics and
will include information on how to receive the newsgroup(s) by e-mail.  If
you do not regularly read lugnet.* newsgroups but want to follow the
discussion on naming, you can view (and optionally participate) using the
web interface:
<http://www.lugnet.com/news/display.cgi?lugnet.admin.general>



Message is in Reply To:
  Informal CFD: robotics competition newsgroup(s)
 
This is an informal call for discussion regarding the creation of a focused newsgroup/mailing-list for _Robot_Arena_ combat events. The LEGO Mindstorms Robot Arena homepage (not sponsored by The LEGO Group) is located at: (URL) takes place in San (...) (26 years ago, 13-Jan-99, to lugnet.admin.general, lugnet.robotics)

80 Messages in This Thread:



























Entire Thread on One Page:
Nested:  All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:  All | Brief | Compact
    

Custom Search

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR