Subject:
|
Re: Fwd from a builder: Colors don't match, among other things!
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.general, lugnet.dear-lego
|
Date:
|
Tue, 18 Nov 2003 02:23:24 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
9190 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.general, Peter F. Guenther wrote:
> > What I didn't agree with was the logic being used to suggest why these changes
> > were being made. I was trying to express my disbelief that changes were
> > happening because parts were getting too difficult to manufacture. If these
> > changes are, in fact, happening the likely reason is either cost/profit or
> > patent related.
>
> Right--I don't agree with that either. It's not a manufacturing issue or a
> cost-saving issue, it's a marketing thing probably based on ease of assembly (if
> it's not a mistake, which I'm still willing to believe based on my Mos Eisley
> experience and other pieces.
So this microscopic change to the studs makes them easier to assemble? Worse
yet, this suggests that today's kids are not as dexterous as we were 25 or 30
years ago? This is really hard to believe. Any average 6 year-old can use
their superior eye --> hand co-ordination to beat me at just about any slick new
video game. And to watch them build with LEGO bricks it's easy to see that
today's kids can still function perfectly well with them. In fact, I once had a
young person tell me that she, "could have built something better if she'd had
the little bricks instead of the big ones." That was the last time I offered
her Duplo bricks with which to build. :)
Rather than being frustrated or over-challenged by LEGO I think kids are as
capable of building with it today - in it's current form - as they were 20, 30
or 40 years ago. Again, I can't possibly fathom that a change to the knob and
tube system is a result of the marketing folks running to management screaming,
"kids can't put the bricks together anymore!!! We must make it simpler for
them!!!"
To hint that kids are having trouble aligning LEGO bricks is to not give credit
to today's very smart children.
From the stories I hear from parents with whom I work today's kids don't have
trouble putting bricks together. Is someone else aware of this being a problem?
Is the company besieged with calls and emails proclaiming, "my child can't get
their LEGO bricks lined up so that they will stick together!!!" Is there
evidence that this is happening?
> > The key (for the company) is to make sure that each change is better than what it is
> > replacing. New hinge plates are an example of where they might have been better
> > off not making a change.
>
> Right--but "better" is relative to the audience, and they have another audience
> in mind than us AFOLs. (Whether the change is better for kids either is
> debatable.)
Kids are more likely to use the click hinges over and again... possibly more
than adults... possibly wearing them out sooner. It was just an example, but I
think it actually holds water in this context. I wasn't attempting to preach a
pro-adult agenda, merely suggesting that companies need to pay attention to what
types of changes they make. The history (and in part the decline) of the
Meccano system was ripe with good and bad changes.
> > But to follow some of the other suggestions in this thread I should be giving up
> > LEGO bricks and building
>
> I'm not about to. If other AFOLs do, then hey! More Lego pieces for me. I've
> put the new color pieces together with old ones and while I wouldn't have chosen
> the effect, it's not unpleasant.
And I'm not about to either. :)
I was using hyperbole to suggest that if I listened to all of the panic
mongering that has gone on in this thread I would be following a ridiculous
course of action. I don't think anyone will or should give up LEGO building
because of these changes. If the changes are good, they will be adopted as a
long-term solution. If they don't, then the company is just as likely to try
something else... for reasons likely unknown to any of us. It's just not worth
fussing over these changes, especially when there's little any of us could do to
alter the natural progression of a consumer product like this.
All the best,
Allan B.
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
Message is in Reply To:
86 Messages in This Thread:
 
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
This Message and its Replies on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
