Subject:
|
Re: Ewok Holocaust
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.starwars
|
Date:
|
Fri, 26 Jan 2001 07:14:23 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
1378 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.starwars, James Simpson writes:
> In lugnet.starwars, Frank Filz writes:
>
> > I'd challenge you to find much SF which you couldn't find gaping holes in. Star
> > Wars is no worse than movies in general, and perhaps better. Note that the
> > referenced article even points out that there is nothing in the Star Wars
> > literature which really conflicts with the analysis, and even material which
> > supports it. Perhaps Lucas is smarter than we think. Perhaps he deliberately
> > created the scenario to challenge us to really think about the story and really
> > question if the heros are really as heroical as first impression would lead one
> > to believe.
>
> I disagree with you.
>
> Chapter I.
>
> ANH was a marvelous epic. Sure, the plot was nothing innovative - basically a
> new version of the classic hero/redemption plot - but it was good nonetheless.
> It was even Art.
>
> II. Empire came along, and it had a dark edge to it. Not many compromises for
> the kiddies. Then...
>
> III. The sad fall from grace. ROTJ was, frankly, IMO a sell-out. It was poorly
> scripted with a redundant plot, had no hard edges, no great revelations, and the
> teddy bear core whupped' **s on the Stormtroopers. Heck, even Vader just looked
> like some benign old grandpa. In 1983, Lucas just cashed in on mass-market
> commercialism to the nth degree. Sure, that hype there prior to TESB, but I
> think that Lucas still held his artistic vision through 1980.
>
> IV. 1999. Bitter tears. We all know that TPM was all beauty and no brains...eye
> candy, but no substance. Lame and predictable, neither hot nor cold...it was,
> to borrow a phrase from Alvin Plantiga, "a nauseating brew, fit for neither man
> nor beast." IOW, it was all about crass commercialization...something goofy for
> the kids, something for the soccer moms, and plenty of room for Jar Jar pez
> dispensers.
>
> In short, I disagree that Lucas is the grand mastermind who is subtely asking us
> to look inward and comtemplate the evil side of heroism, or some such business.
> ROTJ was disneyfied, and TPM was no better! I might buy your argument had this
> event occured in a movie the caliber of TESB, but we had 16 years to contemplate
> the staining of SW, and then were handed a half-done piece of nonsense. No,
> Lucas catered to the least-common-denominator in his last two movies: mass-
> market fluff. Bull in a China Shop, I say.
>
> *Please note: I dislike, as you may note, both ROTJ and TPM, but I mean no
> offense to those who may feel otherwise.
>
> james
Amen. A Dream to some... A Nightmare to others!
Aaron
:o)
|
|
Message is in Reply To:
 | | Re: Ewok Holocaust
|
| (...) I disagree with you. Chapter I. ANH was a marvelous epic. Sure, the plot was nothing innovative - basically a new version of the classic hero/redemption plot - but it was good nonetheless. It was even Art. II. Empire came along, and it had a (...) (26 years ago, 25-Jan-01, to lugnet.starwars)
|
24 Messages in This Thread:
 
 
 
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
