Subject:
|
Re: Chapter 2, plus 2 MOCs, too
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.castle
|
Date:
|
Tue, 8 Apr 2003 03:10:01 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
1637 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.castle, Matt Hein writes:
> In lugnet.castle, Bruce Hietbrink writes:
>
> > Matt, I really think you're doing yourself a
> > disservice here. You are really missing out
> > on one of the best books of the 20th century
> > of any genre, and quite probably THE best in
> > the fantasy genre.
"Frankenstein" is definitely the best fantasy book.
> The only disservice I don't want to do to
> myself is draw from something so starkingly
> obvious that someone can point to it and say
>
> 'there's another mindless tolkein fan! See,
> I told you nobody can write a fantasy story
> without dwarves/ elves.'
I agree with Matt. It is impossible to read something and not pull from it.
I think reading something like LOTR would have too much influence and
frankly i do not wish to be sucked into the vortex of "typical fantasy".
Admittedly, I have some of the elements in my story but they are very
limited (i think). The trouble it seems is that too many people fall into
the traditional fantasy mold of Dragons, orcs and elves that rather than
being truely fantastic become a chip of the block. While these qualities
dont ensure the work is bad, it doesn't seem as interesting.
>
> Right now, I feel like drawing from other
> sources besides tolkein, since I'm going
> for a science fiction/ fantasy story, not
> completely fantasy...and I'd rather not
> have one object possess an ostensible amount
> of power. That would be too simple...
I fear that my great powerstones of Sirob may fall victim to that artifact
of ultimate power (or do they?)
>
> > The answer to avoiding being a copycat is not to
> > avoid the original sources. The answer is instead
> > to read lots and lots of sources--read Tolkien, read
> > L'Engle, read Lewis, read Le Guin, read McCafferty,
> > read Cooper, read the mythology of the Greeks and
> > Norse and other cultures, read the Bible and other
> > religious works, read etc etc etc.
I don't really read much fantasy. Most of my background is from video games.
I think the best influences are from great literary sources. Don't be
afraid of a little Dickens or Fitzgerald. a few stanzas of Shelley never
hurt. Elements of classics like "the Three Musketeers" and various others
run throughout my story. Also, since lego based stories are also visual,
movies help alot. My Jahmong Shrine developed after watching Jackie Chan's
"Spiritual Kung-Fu"
>
> Oh, yeah...you can definitely bet I'd read into
> any of the aforementioned works, except for
> Tolkien...I'll read anything stephen King,
> I'll read Ray Bradbury, heck, I'm even reading
> the bible, and I might check out the Koran and
> assorted Japanese works, but no Tolkien. I'm
> watching some James Bond movies, saw Swordfish
> (very interesting), playing some Metal Gear,
> and reading stories of basically anyone else,
> but still avoiding Tolkein.
>
> I feel if I can pull off writing a fantasy
> project without utilizing Tolkein as a
> reference, that should be considered a feat
> within itself.
Personally I think the best Fantasy is that which is completely created by
the author
>
> > Once you have all these different things swimming
> > around in your head, sure, you'll pull influences
> > from here and there, but it won't be a rip-off of
> > any one book. In interview after interview I have
> > seen professional writers say how reading has helped
> > them grow as writer. Remember, Tolkien drew inspiration
> > from all kinds of sources.
>
> Oh, definitely! You wouldn't believe all of the
> odd science fiction ideas I conceived that
> could be successfully integrated into fantasy
> such as
>
> magic > environ manipulation
magic> interaction of various isotopes of Rydium
> religious faith > influence of the seeds
Religious Faith> Worship the creator (i wonder who that is?)
>
> You know, I'm considering writing a
> terminology digest to log in all of
> these ideas...
>
> And notice, I didn't use Tolkein to
> conceive these! • Good job!
>
> http://www.lugnet.com/~1112/Glossary/ZeroYear
>
> <<_Matt Hein_>>
> Fellow lego enthusiast
> O s p r e y
>
> http://www.lugnet.com/~1112/Creations
I really like the points Matt made and just wanted to add a few more. I
think the key is just originality. If you take an idead from another
sourse, make it your own. Do the orcs always have to be barbaric evil
hordes and why are dwarves so frickin short. ('cause they are Dwarves,
stupid) oh. I guess Tolkein is good but it is his fantasy world and so we
should each create our own original ones too.
-Nick
http://mywebpages.comcast.net/oranzinr
http://www.mocpages.com/home.php/57?r=800163069
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
 | | Re: Chapter 2, plus 2 MOCs, too
|
| (...) The movie 'Resident Evil' gave me some excellent ideas for writing, albeit I might only take a few of them...maybe mix some of that with the 'World is not enough' James Bond film... (...) Hell, I'd like to see a fantasy spoof similar to this, (...) (22 years ago, 8-Apr-03, to lugnet.castle)
|
Message is in Reply To:
| | Re: Chapter 2, plus 2 MOCs, too
|
| (...) The only disservice I don't want to do to myself is draw from something so starkingly obvious that someone can point to it and say 'there's another mindless tolkein fan! See, I told you nobody can write a fantasy story without dwarves/ elves.' (...) (22 years ago, 8-Apr-03, to lugnet.castle)
|
22 Messages in This Thread:
 
 
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
This Message and its Replies on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
