To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.roboticsOpen lugnet.robotics in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 Robotics / 886 (+20)
  Re: legOS
 
Lageson, Tom wrote in message <813599F6EBBFD011B40...co.com>... (...) This is, in fact, the nub of the question at hand. If I buy ANY single board computer with proprietary firmware on it, I can choose to replace the firmware and as a consequence (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
In reality i dont see what the point of this discussion is: .. the work being done on LegOS is only likely to sell more MS units.. (since you need the RCX to use LegOS .. so TLG is not likely to loose money because of the work done by LegOS or NQC (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
Regardless, all software written by Lego is their property. If you want to redistribute it you must obtain permission. If you want to modify it for your own personal use I don't think there is anything they can do to you. Even if the licensing (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
(...) I don't think TLG has much to gain by trying to stop replacement software/firmware for RCX. However it seems much more likely that they would try to prevent the use of the name "lego" in legOS. I used to work for a company that had a very (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
I'm afraid there is no issue we got sidetracked, I think it is time to close this thread on the conclusion we agree about: 1) There is no copyright issue with legOS since it doesn't use any lego code. 2) Lego will not support any RCX with legOS (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: Cybermaster Sensors
 
Nice observation! Do you have any pictures of such an arrangement posted anywhere? Bill (...) if (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: RE: Surveillance Robot
 
Did somebody see a brochure or any other printed matter about the Mars exploration set? David -----Mensaje original----- De: Alex Brinsmead [mailto:AlexB@taproduce.com] Enviado el: Lunes 30 de Noviembre de 1998 06:56 PM Para: dcolomer@openbank.es (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: Cybermaster Sensors
 
There's a picture of this in either the RIS or EC 'opedia. It works wonderfully. I have a picture of a small modification I made to eliminate the dead zone between two sensors. Without it my rover had a tendency to get stuck on table legs, etc... (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
(...) Where did you see that? It didn't catch my eye. -Kekoa (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
(...) The issue at stake is not the copyright. It's the license agreement. -Kekoa (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
(...) And I should add, as Brian pointed out, that the question is not whether firmware is software, it's whether firmware is Software. As I said when I started all of this, read your license agreement again, and tell me whether or not it's obvious (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
It was printed on its own page, which seemed to be a last minute addendum/add-in to the package, and covered that fact plus the warnings against reverse engineering. Perhaps its not included in the earlier mindstorms boxes? I'm at work currently, (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
(...) The issue of the license agreement does state one is not given permission to reverse engineer 'the Software'. The software is defined as 'The Software included on the MINDSTORMS LEGOI product'. I read this as including the firmware. That being (...) (28 years ago, 30-Nov-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
However, the US export limitations _are_ different. PGP is shipped to europe by printing the source in very large books, that are then OCRed in and compiled (at least, that's the official story :) ) Could be the difference is in the fact that it's (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: Cybermaster Sensors
 
In message <4.1.19981130151041....lepac.pt>, Laurentino Martins <lau@mail.telepac.pt> writes (...) Yes, the example of a bump sensor that I was looking at in the book had a sensor on either end of the bumper ( overlapping 2x8 lego plates) so that (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
My take on the issue: Does the legOS violate any copyright laws or licensing? If it was not reveresed engineered from the existing RCX OS - in a word, no. If it was, thats a whol different story - the license agreement would be in violation. As long (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
I've read that it is illegal to ship PGP in source form, though. But this is a very different issue, dealing with a munitions and not copyright law per se. And all of this has little to do with Lego robots. -----Original Message----- From: Jasper (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
Kekoa Proudfoot wrote in message ... (...) Oh, I forgot to comment on this. Companies are patent crazy, if it's not done the "usual" way, they'll try to patent it, EVEN IF IT SEEMS LIKE ANYONE COULD FIGURE IT OUT. The IR transmission is a bit (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  RE: legOS
 
(...) New name? How about: 50937? (or, if the 9 doesn't curl under enough, 50637) -jrs ___...___ \/|/\ | Jason Simpson | Un*x, Mac, and Windows; all-purpose geek /\|\/ | jason@xio.com | Send spam to: treet@slumberland.seattle.wa.us (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)
 
  Re: legOS
 
(...) That's what you'd think. But if this was how TLG thought, they would have published the specs for talking to the Control Lab. In fact TLG is notoriously - I was going to say "hostile to", but "uninterested in" is closer to the truth - its (...) (28 years ago, 1-Dec-98, to lugnet.robotics)

Next Page:  5 more | 10 more | 20 more
Redisplay Messages:  All | Compact

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR