Subject:
|
Re: Can you folks give any more info on this?
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.loc.au
|
Date:
|
Thu, 29 Aug 2002 04:51:40 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
384 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.loc.au, Kerry Raymond writes:
>
> The census is covered by a framework of legislation that restricts the
> legitimate ways that census data can be used by the government, the purpose of
> which is to protect the privacy of individuals. The reason that you have to
> identify yourself is because it is well-known in surveying that anonymous
> surveys get less accurate responses than those with identification. So the
> identification is to improve the data quality rather than an interest per se in
> who you actually are. I rather suspect that to check someone was lying and then
> prosecute them for doing so would almost certainly breach the legitimate uses
> of census data somewhere along the line (I'm sure a lawyer would be happy to
> argue this in court!). So identifying yourself and having a fine for lying are
> basically to encourage people to tell the truth, in the belief that they can be
> fined if they don't. However, the realistic likelihood of this happening is
> probably 0.
One legitimate way is to sell the data to commercial interests.
Now they should ask questions about Lego, TLC/G could use that sort of info.
You can neglect to answer certain questions, just answer truthfully.
> Also, I would like to see the court case in which we proved a Jedi-worshipper
> was lying. It rather begs the question of getting a definition of religion and
> a basis for testing a person's beliefs. How do we prove that someone is a
> Catholic? I bet a lot of people identified on the census as Catholics haven't
> been to church in years and probably say and do things not consistent with the
> "beliefs" of Catholicism. Were they lying about being Catholic?
>
> Personally I've attended all services of the Jedi faith (Episodes 1,2,4,5,and
> 6, some multiple times) and I have a number of books and icons (plastic images
> of Jedi saints, e.g. a large Yoda and various keyrings, all sold by S@H
> incidentally) in my house further attesting to my devotion to the Jedi
> religion. I have certainly attended more Jedi events than any other religions
> in the past couple of decades.
I only saw the first-half of Ep.2, I'll bet they ask questions on the 2nd-half.
(note: The multiplex projector went off the rails). Note to self - must put the
Yoda back together.
Dave Drew mentioned the following...
> > 2. The CNN article isn't wholly correct. Some names and addresses are
> > kept by the ABS. There was an option where you can choose to release all
> > of your census answers after 100 years have elapsed. I'm sure the people
> > of the future will be just thrilled to find out that I live in St.
> > Lucia, and have no children.
>
> Yes, they will be thrilled and thank you for doing it (about half of the
> population did agree to preserve their data for historical purposes). I am
> someone who uses census records from the UK in the 1800s and I love them.
> Indeed, it was only the fact that I am someone who uses 100-year-released
> census data, and hence do value its accuracy, that stopped me from claiming
> adherence to the Jedi religion myself.
Followers of genie-ology must rely on there being no non-matrimonial events
or mystery donors fouling the stream.
> What I think the Jedi-on-the-census form "proves" is that an increasingly large
> number of Australians thought it was an irrelevant question to ask in the first
> place, which is consistent with the highest ever response of "No Religion" also
> recorded in this census.
pete.w (the truth is in the ABS)
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
Message is in Reply To:
 | | Re: Can you folks give any more info on this?
|
| (...) The census is covered by a framework of legislation that restricts the legitimate ways that census data can be used by the government, the purpose of which is to protect the privacy of individuals. The reason that you have to identify yourself (...) (22 years ago, 28-Aug-02, to lugnet.loc.au)
|
12 Messages in This Thread:
  
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
This Message and its Replies on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
