Subject:
|
Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set)
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.trains
|
Date:
|
Wed, 30 Mar 2005 19:35:37 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
5376 times
|
| |
![Post a public reply to this message](/news/icon-reply.gif) | |
In lugnet.trains, Samarth Moray wrote:
> In lugnet.trains, Jan-Albert van Ree wrote:
>
> > With engines I always try to build to scale as far as possible, with coaches
> > this usually isn't possible due to length vs curve radius and a few other
> > practical limitations. Around 50-60 studs would be the max for length of
> > any rail vehicle. Otherwise you'll get something like this :
> > http://www.brickshelf.com/cgi-bin/gallery.cgi?i=1135688
> > The cars look great, but are impossible to run in a miniland layout.
>
> I think it all boils down to what PURPOSE you want your train MOC to have.
> Whether you want it to be just a beautiful display piece, to run on a layout, or
> hey, even a mixture of the two. A good example of the former would be this model
> (IMO) and/or Shaun Sullivan's Hudson (see the .trains sidebar)
Agreed, those models aren't built primarily for their running qualities.
> and a good
> example of the latter would be Lar's ATSF
Except that I found out (second hand, I wasn't there, I was in S'pore) that it's
not as good a runner as I had hoped. Needs tuning on a big layout... Sigh. I
agree about INTENT though!
> or any James Mathis stuff,
Some of JM's earlier virtual only stuff needed tuning when people tried to build
it real world too.
> or official TLC stuff too.
Except when it doesn't run well. Sigh.
None of that should be taken as disagreement with your basic point, which is,
WHAT are you building for?
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
Message is in Reply To:
![](/news/x.gif) | | Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set)
|
| (...) I think it all boils down to what PURPOSE you want your train MOC to have. Whether you want it to be just a beautiful display piece, to run on a layout, or hey, even a mixture of the two. A good example of the former would be this model (IMO) (...) (19 years ago, 30-Mar-05, to lugnet.trains)
|
61 Messages in This Thread: ![D&RGW coach set -Steven Barile (28-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Steven Barile (28-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -John Neal (28-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -John Barnes (28-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Larry Pieniazek (28-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Robin Werner (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Larry Pieniazek (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Steven Barile (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Robin Werner (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -John Gerlach (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Timothy Gould (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Steven Barile (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Timothy Gould (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -James Mathis (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Tim David (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Tim David (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Steven Barile (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Tim David (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Larry Pieniazek (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: D&RGW coach set -Reinhard "Ben" Beneke (29-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Didier Enjary (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Tim David (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Larry Pieniazek (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Tim David (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Larry Pieniazek (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Jonathan Reynolds (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -John Neal (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Eggliners (was Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set)) -Tim David (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Eggliners (was Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set)) -John Neal (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Eggliners (was Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set)) -Larry Pieniazek (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -David Koudys (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Scott E. Sanburn (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -John Neal (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -David Koudys (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Tim David (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -John Neal (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Larry Pieniazek (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Larry Pieniazek (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains, lugnet.off-topic.fun)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Jason Spears (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains, lugnet.off-topic.fun)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -John Neal (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Christopher Masi (5-Apr-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Jan-Albert van Ree (5-Apr-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Larry Pieniazek (6-Apr-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -John Gerlach (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -Jason J. Railton (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -Mark Bellis (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -Larry Pieniazek (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -John Kelly III (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -John Neal (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -John Gerlach (31-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/268.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Jan-Albert van Ree (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/246.gif) ![You are here](/news/here.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Samarth Moray (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/28.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism (D&RGW coach set) -Jan-Albert van Ree (30-Mar-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/68.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -Didier Enjary (4-Apr-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif) ![](/news/46.gif) ![Re: Compressionism -Steven Barile (5-Apr-05 to lugnet.trains)](/news/x.gif)
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
This Message and its Replies on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|