Subject:
|
Re: My Episode II Rant
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.starwars
|
Date:
|
Wed, 8 Dec 2004 02:58:14 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
2606 times
|
| |
|
|
At 12:31 PM 8/12/2004, you wrote:
> Hi all my first Star Wars post. I know it's not strictly Lego related but I
> think that's ok from other posts I've seen.
Hey I'm always up for a Rant, let's get it ON!
> Ok back story wise here's what's wrong:
>
> Tuskan raiders do not distinguish between gender in their dress. This
> contradiction can be seen in Galactic battlegrounds: Clone Campaigns and
> the Ep.
> II Visual Dictionary in which their clothes vary. It clearly says this is not
> the case in The Illustrated Star Wars Universe.
Good point, as Anakin states that he killed them all, the women and the
children, it would have been nice to at least glimpse the women and
children of the sand people. And where are the sand people in Clone Campaigns?
> The Geonosians did not design the Death Star as implied by the presence of the
> holo-plans removed by Count Dooku in the closing scenes of the movie. The
> Death
> Star was conceived by Grand Moff Tarkin and approved by the Emperor as
> described
> in Star Wars Essential Guide to Vehicles and Vessels. This implies that the
> Empire had to exist already and Tarkin had to be a Grand Moff (whatever
> that may
> be. some one set me straight on that please.). Thus it could not have been
> designed before hand.
George has stated before that the Movies are the number one source of Star
Wars facts. the multitudes of books that have spawned from his creation
can be over ridden by the prequal movies. this is but one of those
things. However it is interesting in that this movies is, what, 22 years
before ANH and the Death Star is only just patrolling the galaxy then, yet
the second Death Star, which is bigger, is up and operational a measly 5
years (this figure may be wrong, correct it if it is) after the first one
is destroyed. However, maybe the production of the first is slowed because
it is kept secret, I don't know.
I do, however, find it amusing that every Star Wars book after the GOD
AWFUL Jedi Academy trilogy has now been invalidated. That's what you get
for writing such a HORRIBLE trilogy of books Mr Anderson! I take
issueswith that trilogy. it was just bad.
> Battle droids are a product of Baktoid Armor Workshop not a Geonosian
> factory of
> some kind although the design could have been licensed out I suppose.
it was ten years, maybe companies have changed hands, or it's a product of
the separatist alliance or something. needs a little explanation I agree
> I probably missed a couple dozen others so feel free to add!
nope, I'm good
> Movie problems (or my subjective opinions):
> Bad dialogue, the characters sound like cheesy spoofs of themselves from the
> previous episode.
ah, It's Star Wars, I can over look that.
> No extras or actors were used for any of the clone trooper scenes, digital
> only.
> This made them seem to robot-ish and inhuman (in a bad different way from
> storm
> troopers).
ah, not entirely true, but yeah, true for the bigger scenes, but in those,
who is looking for humanity
> Dexter (that four armed alien from the dinner scene). I personally
> nominate him
> for dumbest and most annoying prequel character. Like Jar-Jar he was
> unnecessary
> addition that made the film stall.
nah, I like Dexter, gave Obi Wan some street cred, and we know that Obi Wan
knows his stuff, has to learn it from somewhere
> Jango fett's Armor is a different color and style than Boba's in the
> originals.
> AND we see Jango without his helmet! In addition, his pistols look like some
> decorative piece made for a rich collector not tactical at all (although
> the way
> he used them at the same time was cool).
so is the Slave One, in the same variations too. So Boba is good with
paint, likes green over blue, and sliver becomes grey over time. the
pistols reminded me of the Queen's pistols in Episode I
> No big space battle. The one between Obi Wan and Jango doesn't count. That was
> just lame Obi Wan never fires a shot.
I would have liked a space battle too, but you can't always have space
battles. we did get an awesome ground battle though
> The eh-hem "car chase" thing with the air speeders. Just plain stupid
> trying to
> put a car chase into star wars form.
I felt it gave us an interesting view of Corasaunt that we have never seen
before (did I even spell that correctly?) and I liked the car chase (I
still haven't found the Tie Fighter or the X-Wing that are apparently in
one of the Corasaunt scenes)
> Obi Wan's lame saber fighting in general.
yeah, a little disappointing, one saber throw and "pop" off with Jango's
head on Kimeno (again, planet name spelling?)
> The rickshaw things on Tatooine never seen in any other movie.
but looking at Tatooine (and I know I spelt this one right) it's not unexpected
> Not even showing one pod racer making them similarly reference less.
A broken one outsides Watto's shop would have been nice, but the budget was
spent on the Rickshaw I guess. (and did I see a single power coupling beam
on that Rickshaw.... I think NOT)
> And last but not least all those lame jokes that Threepio makes during the
> battle. Bad. Awful. Terrible. Abominable. Running out of adjectives.
Hello? Threepio, bad jokes abound! I liked the jokes to be honest. need I
remind people of the link between "Lame" and "Star Wars"
> The fight between Obi Wan and Anakin should have taken place in Ep. II and
> then
> the rise of the Empire in and the Alliance in Ep. III
I feel, that given what we know has to have happened by the end of Episode
III that there was a lot left out, but I'm not sure what else could have
been put in. Episode Three needs to be like 3 1/2 hours long
> Ok, I'm done.
really, I'm just getting warmed up.
nah, just joshing ya, I'm done
Nice ranting with ya Peter
Leg Godt
Travis Matheson
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
 | | Re: My Episode II Rant
|
| Thanks for your input! Always nice to get other people’s opinion about the stuff I love. (...) In CC the Sand People are in the Tatooine based scenarios in the Republic and Confederacy campaigns. You can also find them in the scenario editor either (...) (20 years ago, 8-Dec-04, to lugnet.starwars)
|
Message is in Reply To:
| | My Episode II Rant
|
| Hi all my first Star Wars post. I know it’s not strictly Lego related but I think that’s ok from other posts I’ve seen. Just my Ep. II rant. Wanted to generate some discussion because my digital camera is broken and I can’t post MOCs. Ok back story (...) (20 years ago, 8-Dec-04, to lugnet.starwars)
|
5 Messages in This Thread:
  
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
This Message and its Replies on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
