Subject:
|
Re: The Two Towers : New poster at www.rotule.qc.ca
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.general
|
Date:
|
Tue, 24 Jun 2003 16:39:26 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
398 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.general, Terry Prosper wrote:
> Whaaaa?
>
> I admit, I didn't expect such hard ratings. I'm very doubtful that this postr
> is *that* bad. So far, 4 persons have voted 0/10, which means that they think
> it is absolutely horrible.
>
> I've asked both my better-half and my best friend for their opinion on the votes
> so far and on my poster. Here is their input :
>
> Samaelle (wife): 10/10
>
> Vincent (friend) : 9/10 "People who rated it 0 are just stupid, obviously.
> While it's not your best poster, it's still very good. And "not your best one"
> doesn't mean a thing...[because some of your other posters are awesome]"
>
> My personnal opinion : I think this poster is very good. I'd place it between
> Fight Club (http://www.rotule.qc.ca/posters/showposter.cgi?fightclub) and Harry
> Potter Chamber of
> Secrets(http://www.rotule.qc.ca/posters/showposter.cgi?hpchamber)
>
> But I will accept criticism. Vincent told me it's got to much Photoshop editing
> for his taste. Maybe that's why this poster is not well rated? But even so,
> rating it zero is pure stupidity. I've never rated a poster 0. The worst
> poster I've rated got a 2 i think. I don't think I would put a "0" poster on my
> website anyway! :-)
I rated it a 5 before I read this post, here is why. I think the poster is good,
and had I not seen some of your other work I would have problably given it an 8.
I was just prejudiced by some of your awesome previous works. I love the concept
of your site, and the execution, but I prefer the posters that make more use of
Lego elements rather than photoshop.
My personal favorites are Harry Potter: The sourcerer stone, The Fellowship of
the Rings, Jaws, Ghostbusters, and Good Morning Vietnam. So my 5 is in
comparison to some of the great ones.
Scott C.
|
|
Message is in Reply To:
 | | Re: The Two Towers : New poster at www.rotule.qc.ca
|
| Whaaaa? I admit, I didn't expect such hard ratings. I'm very doubtful that this postr is *that* bad. So far, 4 persons have voted 0/10, which means that they think it is absolutely horrible. I've asked both my better-half and my best friend for (...) (21 years ago, 23-Jun-03, to lugnet.general)
|
8 Messages in This Thread:
  
 
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
