To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.admin.generalOpen lugnet.admin.general in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 Administrative / General / 6314 (+20)
  Rating websites.... (was: opinions on rating)
 
(...) If you consider this original purpose, CLSotW has definitely lived up to it and much more! I look forward to the new pick every week, and I usually check out the nominations too. I think it's a great thing as is and should not be mixed with (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Idea: New Rating System
 
I already dropped this idea in an earlier post. Although it was highly rated nobody responded, so I thought I'd put it out here in a separate thread and not buried in the midst of my feelings about the current rating system. The idea in question is (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
 
(...) There are two ways, currently -- but they're designed to work without getting in the way (rather than to be obvious). First way: If two people like a message a lot (and, say, each mark it 100), then it has a lower composite score than, say, (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) I can't pinpoint any concrete examples of elitism, per se...but,upon reflection I can see where some debates degenerated into lowballing of comments from opposing perspectives ...I view Lugnet as a Microcosm of the internet information (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: the latest news
 
(...) For a few days I was thinking that too. But then I realized "I don't care," and also "I have no idea who rated this" -- they could be out to lunch for all I know, either for the duration of rating my article, or permanently. Or they could be (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: the latest news
 
(...) Short note: in the temporary "top 40" page Todd put up, at least 50% (if not more, I didn't count) of the posts were related to the discussion about the rating. That's too bad, because it shouldn't be (AFAI gathered from Todd's POV on what (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) That's probably even better. Gonna try out a related thing first -- changing the "+" symbols to "!" symbols. The "!" symbol is a lot skinnier than "+", so it saves precious space, and the count of symbols isn't really as important anyway as (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
In lugnet.announce, Todd Lehman writes: <snip> (...) It doesn't matter to me. (...) It doesn't matter to me. (...) Worse, slightly .. The feature does have its benefits. (...) No. I don't find validation in what others think of my stuff. I ask for (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) symbols. (...) No, but I see how other people might. (...) <snip> Yes, definitely yes. If your post isn't recommended, it doesn't mean anything... just that it's not recommended. No hard feelings (or at least less hard than "low ratings"). (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: the latest news
 
(...) Except for the fact that the message-group filter isn't applied there, it's actually working perfectly well, IMHO. The ratings are, in the final analysis, recommendations-to-read. If the original message and its replies are getting high (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Also thinking of making a rating of 0 (lowest) not count -- i.e., be exactly the same as inputting no opinion at all. In other words, there would be a way not to recommend to read something (naturally) but no way to recommend not to read (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
 
(...) Yes, I understand that, but what about two people liking a message a lot vs. several dozen saying that it's mediocre? Those are quite different. (...) Ah. Yes, that's much better. (Does MS Win still only use 20 colors for text, or can you use (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Yeah, I agree that "+" has connotations of "better". But I think the "!" seems to have a "Warning" feeling to it, especially in red. (It's a typical icon in warning error message dialog boxes, for example.) That doesn't mean it's necessarily a (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  (canceled)
 
 
  Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
 
(...) Two people liking a message a lot would have a composite score of 60 to 70. Several dozen saying that it's mediocre would have a composite score of 0 to 30, depending on how you define "mediocre." A low score with a lot of input shows up dark (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Welp, space isn't really _that_ much of an issue compared to the symbol itself. All things being equal, a thinner character is better than a big fat character like "+". Let's see what people think about "!" after seeing it for a little (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
 
(...) Oh -- one other thing -- Orange also has this property. Red and Yellow are the two most attention-getting colors to humans. --Todd (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Did I read that yet?
 
I have been making sure that I rate at least the last article I have read in each news area, then when I go back later from a different browser or even the same one, I can just chase back to the last article that I rated...... Paul Foster (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
 
(...) I agree. And (guess what I'm going to say next *grin*) I think the "one button" idea lends itself to this. (...) The problem was that only 2 of those 20 were red.... (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) For what it's worth, slrn uses ! to mark highly-scored (via my own score file) articles. So I'm certainly used to it. (I thought it kind of odd of slrn too, but no one asked me for feedback there....) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  

Next Page:  5 more | 10 more | 20 more
Redisplay Messages:  All | Compact

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR