 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) I think that your rating concept has potential, but is incurring "issues in interprtation and implementation" (...) I browse Lugnet liesurely and often ( I have more time than most-I work out of my home) I can sympathize w/ those who are (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: New feature: Article rating
|
|
(...) It's been far more than that. It was first brought up in November. (...) Likely before the end of April. It's not a crisis situation. (...) Heard you the first 3 times. Agreed twice. --Todd (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) articles are ones expressing dissatisfaction or concern with the rating system.... as the old saying goes, you can vote yourself OUT of a democracy but you can't vote yourself back into one. If the ratings system survives in some form, this (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) The minus signs still look damaging, and I don't think it's good that a default of 1 (20 internally) can be lowered to 0 by a single person casting a 0. (20+0)/2 = 10, which becomes 0, which becomes "-". Might tweak this tomorrow, either to... (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) Better (...) So so. If the feature is to be kept, prefer that they be viewable. Else why have them. (...) Better. Wish the time had never been spent to develop them. (...) Victimized? Hardly. Annoyed that there's a strategic rater out there (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) This looks like a much better rating system. And I agree that any given article shouldn't be given a negative rating without further explanation. If someone continuously receives negative ratings for their posts, they might take it as their (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) This is the best option I think, at least better than the option below (which I was thinking as the best, until reading your message). It doesn't included the feeling of "elitism is at the front door" by satisfying an automated "top n list" (...) (27 years ago, 10-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
|
|
It is clear from the debate raging further down the group (as NNTP newsreaders see it :) ) that one of the fundamental flaws with ratings at the moment is that there is no criteria for ratings posts. This in turn means that the ratings themselves (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: What should be done about ratings
|
|
"Ben Roller" <broller@mail.clemson.edu> wrote in message news:FtC0nK.AGL@lugnet.com... (...) Perhaps rating can be done in two completely seperate ways. First one rates the quality of the content of the post and second one rates the relevancy. For (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) Hmm. As far as I can see, the main problem is neither the collection _or_ the representation of the data but the data itself. When members vote, they are voting on different things eg: Do I agree with that? Was that worded well? Was it (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: LUGNET getting too complex?
|
|
"Kevin Salm" <kdsalm@dreamscape.com> wrote in message news:FtAx2D.GB2@lugnet.com... (...) example, I (...) As an aside I should point out that Outlook Express 5 is does spot cross-posted messages and marks them as downloaded and read if one has (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
I believe there is a problem that has already been addressed by several people, and that is that the ratings are too vague. If everyone is rating messages based on their own criteria, then we will never be able to use the information that is being (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | side effect of the new rating system.
|
|
Hey did anyone else notice that the compact view seems to take up more space vertically this morning? I have to scroll more. Yuck! I blame the new rating system. Bring back the old one! ;-) By the way, I don't know if this has been said since I'm (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) Well, since you asked, I thought I'd leave mine. (...) This change could be for the better. I was fine with the 100 scale (I think the 5 scale gives less acurate results) but it's good if it makes rating easier for people. Hopefully this will (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
|
|
(...) How about +++ 4 ++ 3 + 2 1 0 ? (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
|
|
In lugnet.admin.general, Nicholas Allan writes: <consider using Relevancy and Quality as dimensions> Agreed that these are two. I nominated Newsworthiness and Long Term Usefulness as well. A post that told us all of a huge and very cheap sale that (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general) !
|
| |
 | | Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
|
|
(...) Good suggestions. I'd like to flog my personal dead horse here :) and note that it'd be nice to just have ONE button/checkbox for each scale. You'd still end up with continuum of scores, but based on the total number of people who pressed the (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
|
|
(...) Hey.. there's a cue for dead-horse floggage in this group ;-) (...) It does have some benefits - how would the "off-topic" button work though if the message was cross-posted, and assuming that it wasn't off-topic in every group? Also - that is (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: New feature for messages?
|
|
(...) It works better because there's only one server, which honors canceling. But on the other hand, with that many people reading LUGNET off the mail interface, I'd say canceling works _worse_ than on USENET. You can't cancel a message which has (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|
| |
 | | Re: Creating Lugent Rating Criteria
|
|
(...) Yes, that's a point I hadn't thought of. Hmm. Since having the off-topic score is really important to this whole concept, it might have to be kept seperately for each group the message was posted in. Yuck. (But that's also a problem with the (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
|