Subject:
|
RESULTS- CFV Johnathan Wilson's Posting Priviledges on LUGNET
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.admin.general
|
Date:
|
Mon, 30 Aug 1999 21:02:20 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
371 times
|
| |
|
|
(For a clearer view copy and past into MS Excel or another spreadsheet-
space delimited.)
CFV Results
Name 1a 1b 1c 2 3 3a 3b 3c 3d Com 2a
1 Chris Alano N N N N N - - - - Y -
2 Baumans N Y N N Y Y - - - Y -
3 Tim Courtney Y Y Y Y Y Y - - - Y -
4 Adam Howard N N N N Y - - Y - Y -
5 Mike Stanley Y Y Y Y Y Y - - - Y -
6 J Boen N Y N Y - - - - - Y -
7 Bryce McGlone Y Y Y Y - - - - - Y -
8 Tom McDonald N Y N Y Y - Y - - Y 6 month probation. Violation = 3 flame
posts from 3 separate people
9 Linc Smith N N N N N - - - - Y -
10 Kim Toll N Y N Y Y * Y - - - Y -
11 Leonardo Zide N N N N Y Y - - - Y -
12 Dave Blomberg N N N N N - - - - Y -
13 Anders Isaksson N N N N Y Y - - - Y -
14 Christian Holtje N N N N N - - - - Y -
15 Jaochim Probst N N N N Y - - Y - Y -
16 John VanZwieten N Y N Y Y * Y - - - Y -
17 John Neel N N N N Y - - - nt 1 Y - nt 1: Y- More than 2 flame posts
per 24 hr period
18 Jeremey Sproat N Y N Y Y Y - - - Y -
19 John DiRienzo N N N N Y - Y - - Y -
20 Christopher Tracey N N N N Y Y - - - Y -
Totals(20): 3 8 3 8 Cad 14 9 2 2 1 20 1
7 All
2/3- majority calc 15 40 15 0.4 70 45 10 10 5 100 5
0.35
Results N N N N Y Y N N N All Later Vote
N
* Probation on lugnet.* and banned from lugnet.cad, unless resolution #2
does not pass,
then probation shall include all lugnet.*.
Decision:
Jonathan Wilson will be place on probation for a period of 6 months.
Probation Violation is defined as:
a. 1 new post
by Jonathan that result(s) in a flame message being sent by someone in the
LUGNET community, during the probationary period, that is in relation to
any
of the points discussed in the Problem Summary.
Notes:
A new post by Jonathan would be a new post to any lugnet.* group,
including a reply to an
ongoing thread.
A flame message will be defined as any message that contains
non-constructive criticism,
anger, or complaints directed at Jonathan based on any of the problems
discussed
in the Problem Summary. Flame messages based on problems not described in
the
Problem Summary will not count.
Violation of probation would result in immediately revoking posting
privileges
for a period of six months.
A new vote would be called after the banishment period to determine
further action.
Possible flame posts will be reviewed by a committee.
The first post that is determined to be a flame message, as defined above,
will be submitted to the LUGNET administration to count for the Probation
Violation.
The committee will be made up of all voters casting a vote for any part of
the CFV,
unless you noted otherwise as stated in the CFV.
If you have changed your mind and DO NOT wish to be on this committee
please send me an email and I will remove your name from the committee
list.
If you wish to report a possible violation please send a copy to Adam Howard
at:
abhoward10@hotmail.com
and cc/
Todd Lehman at
lehman@javanet.com
I will forward the possible violation to the committee (note Todd is not a
member of this committee). The committee will take a vote and decide if it
meets the criteria stated in the Probation Violation definition. The result
of that vote will be sent to the LUGNET administration for action/inaction
depending on the committee's decision.
Thank You.
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
15 Messages in This Thread:
   
 
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
