To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.admin.generalOpen lugnet.admin.general in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 Administrative / General / 6253 (+20)
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Todd Lehman skrev i meddelandet ... [...about the rating system...] As I only read via a newsreader (off-line), I don't see the ratings and, even if I had been a member, don't have any opportunity to rate, I find it rather unnecessary. The storms (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Hmm, hmm... Very insightfully put. Hadn't looked at it from the point of view of an "anonymous, public reply." Interesting... --Todd (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) That could be a great application of a detailed rating system... Multi- dimensional too, not just a single number. (...) In terms of websites, I was thinking more along the lines of you telling the server what types of websites you liked best, (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Any suggestions on a better title than "top 40"? If there wasn't already something called "Spotlight," that might be a good name for it. I'm wary that "top 40" sounds possibly like it's putting things up on a pedestal or too much like the (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Todd Lehman wrote in message ... <snip> (...) ratings (...) simple (...) I think most users would activate this setting, if available. That is, it wouldn't likely solve the problems. (...) ratings (...) One idea is that ratings continue to be (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Ratings are making me paranoid!
 
I didn't really pay attention to the rating system til recently...It was instituted and functioning while I was out of town...I don't really understand, even after reading many posts. I think rating could be very helpful in aforementioned groups (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: the latest news
 
(...) No cynicism would be required. Our only evidence actually supports such an argument. -Suz (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) That's a good idea! I'm not sure what you mean by "sample size"; but I think that adding another condition would be useful: -Only display the rating if more than X people have rated it (X = ? Perhaps 5?) Is that what you meant by sample size? (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Todd Lehman <lehman@javanet.com> wrote: <some questions about article rating> i can't really address the questions you asked, but i just wanted to say that i use emacs or slrn to broswe, and they both have great scoring systems, which i use on the (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Todd & All, (...) don't use the system in terms of the website interface, since I get all my LUGNET info from the NNTP. One of the most visible complaints I have of the ratings system is the inability of seeing these ratings on the various postings (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
I have always felt that the ratings given to my posts accurately reflected how interested others would be towards those posts. In fact, if you had asked me to personally rate all of my posts, i probably would have given them the same number. I (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Better (...) Better (...) Better (...) Sort of: not "uncomfortable or unhappy about yourself or about LUGNET" but annoyed and indignant. Only once, because I use a newsreader 99% of the time and don't normally see the ratings. (...) No (...) (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Just look what ratings did to Slashdot!
 
While I'm not particularly interested in directly weighing in on the debate raging over Lugnet's rating system, I will take the time to say this: Look carefully at how rating (they call it Moderation) has affected the Slashdot community. ((URL) I (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Hey Todd, I've been avoiding a direct and complete opinion about the rating system till now, mainly because I wasn't sure of my stand on it. But now I know where I stand... here're my answers: (...) This is a good idea and I'll be glad to ee it (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful?
 
Todd Lehman wrote a bunch of worthy stuff about the rating system. Lugnet hosts an amazing variety of visitors. From my background, the rating system is fine. If I want to rate, I will (which I generally don't). If I want to pay attention to other (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Just look what ratings did to Slashdot!
 
(...) I think you've got the details right, but I'd disgree with your assessment of the result. I'd say that slashdot's moderation system has been quite successful. In the early days, /. was fun to read and had good discussions. But when it passed a (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general) ! 
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) I don't think you need site ratings to do this. If there was some way for a person (whether the site owner or someone else) to "register" a site with the cool links page, and then fill in a form specifying which themes (not just Lego themes, (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) [snip] (...) Good point -- this is kind of what I was trying to say, although I'd taken it to a further extreme. (Even less choices.) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Shiri Dori wrote in message ... (...) think (...) Yes. It doesn't really matter what X is, but 4 or 5 seems reasonable to start with. -- John (remove the obvious to reply) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Just look what ratings did to Slashdot!
 
(...) I have a major problem with their concept of karma, which is why LUGNET's article ratings system doesn't give higher precedence to any particular posters. (...) This is why anyone (any member, that is) can rate anyone else's article at LUGNET. (...) (27 years ago, 21-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  

Next Page:  5 more | 10 more | 20 more
Redisplay Messages:  All | Compact

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR