Subject:
|
Re: Suggested Change in Charter for ALL Lugnet Theme Groups.
|
Newsgroups:
|
lugnet.admin.general
|
Date:
|
Tue, 7 Mar 2000 13:36:40 GMT
|
Viewed:
|
233 times
|
| |
|
|
In lugnet.admin.council, Scott Arthur writes:
> Suggested Change in Charter for ALL Lugnet Theme Groups.
>
> By "theme", I mean castle, space pirate etc.
>
> I suggest the pre-auction announcements should be allowed in all theme
> groups, with the following provisos:
I find it hard to give an opinion about this subject. I don't see a benefit
in it for myself. I check lugnet.fabuland and do a general search on the word
fabuland. Therefore, I now already find the pre-auction announcement if they
contain Fabuland sets.
On the other side these announcements in lugnet.fabuland wouldn't distract me
from other discussions going on there. I think this is the general case for
small newsgroups. In larger newsgroups these announcements may however give
much distraction from the other discussions in the group.
In short: I'm not in favour of allowing pre auction announcements in the
them-groups, but have not large problems with it if it is allowed.
Still I would like to make some comments on the provisos given by Scott in
case it would be allowed. Some large remarks and some minor remarks.
>
> 1. Only privately run auctions should be allowed - _NO_ ebay etc.
Is there a specific reason why there should be a division between privately run
auctions and Ebay ?
The method is the same, only Ebay is better known than a private auction side.
Also what to do with semi-privately auction sides (e.g. a Lego oriented auction
side run by an AFOL, but also open for other people)
> 2. Only _sets_ which relate directly to the theme should be allowed - (ie
> they should by listed under the relevant theme on Pause or Brickset).
Why only sets? I'm not only interested in sets, but also specific
theme-oriented pieces.
> 3. All sets auctioned should be at least 3 years old - this will disallow
> most clearance "box shifters".
The idea is good, but is three years the right period (i.e. why not 2 or 4
years)
> 4. Follow-ups (replies) to the post should be directed to
> Lugnet.market.auction.
Agree
> 5. Auction updates, if any, should be posted to Lugnet.market.auction - NOT
> the theme group.
Agree
> 6. The initial post should only have the title "theme_name PRE AUCTION
> ANNOUNCEMENT" - Nothing more.
Should the theme-name be included? In the castle group itself PRE AUCTION
ANNOUNCEMENT would be sufficient because rule number 2 excludes everything that
is not castle. Also this title might cause many same title in the large
themegroups and therefore, probably also in the market.auction group
> 7. The auction post and terms should be pre-checked by lugnet.admin.council
> to ensure it is "fair" & complies with points 1 to 6.
I think I don't understand how you want to have the pre-checking be done. Could
you explain it a little bit more. (The way I interpret it now is that a
pre-auction announcement should be first mailed to lugnet.admin.council and
after that to the specific theme-group, gnerating twice as much messages)
Greetings,
Sybrand Bonsma
|
|
Message has 1 Reply:
3 Messages in This Thread:
  
- Entire Thread on One Page:
- Nested:
All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:
All | Brief | Compact
|
|
|
|
