To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.admin.generalOpen lugnet.admin.general in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 Administrative / General / 6226 (+20)
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Hi Todd, To be brutally honest, I had some doubts about the rating system when I originally saw it - I wondered how long it would be before somebody decided (say) that they didn't like someone else and started rating all of their posts as '0'. (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
In lugnet.admin.general, Todd Lehman writes: <bulk snip> (...) Indifferent. I've been following along, and have a pretty good idea of what the issues are, but it just doesn't matter much to me. I don't put much stock in the numbers to date, since so (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: A Question on Logging in and posting
 
Thanks, Todd. I thought that this might be the case. I know you're a supergenius, but I'm also aware that nothing happens on it's own. *smile* -Cheese (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Did I read that yet?
 
Todd, I've heard some requests for this before, and I'd like to revisit it. Can we get some sort of flag to show whether we've read a message or not? When I go to another computer, flush out my cache, switch from Netscape to IE, etc, I can't tell if (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Hi Todd, My personal feedback. I think the ratings system has caused me to post less, if that's a concern or not. I haven't felt belittled or berated, but I tend to think nobody reads my posts when I see it rated by less than 3 people and it rated (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Some miscellaneous unordered thoughts: - I would be inclined to say that the rating system is definitely harmfull. I have not seen anyone say "wow, this rating system just helped me read through 2 weeks of posts and catch up on all the important (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
In lugnet.admin.general, Todd Lehman writes: snip,snip,snip... (...) That's probably a good idea (it doesn't worry me) for the sensitive, but people will always be tempted to look at their 'mark' and get upset. (...) I think the rating system has a (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
A couple more thoughts: - Anytime you have a way to compare reactions about things, there is opportunity for people to feel that their contribution wasn't valued. Note that we have someone currently bummed out that they got a lukewarm reaction to (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Did I read that yet?
 
(...) Probably will be done sometime, but it's not a relatively high priority... --Todd (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Did I read that yet?
 
(...) I should comment more on that -- it's lower priority because of its complexity and small gain compared to other things of lesser complexity and higher gain. --Todd (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  What should be done about ratings (Was: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful?)
 
Before I start this message is a response to (URL) have very rarely used the Lugnet News web-interface so I did a little research on the rating system. After twiddling around in the web-based version I discovered that some fundamental issues need to (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Here BTW is a quick example of a "top N" list (N=40)... (URL) just an experimental page, and it may go away without notice. I'll leave it up for at least a few days, though, for feedback. It's updated once hourly by a cron job. The ratings (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general) ! 
 
  Re: Did I read that yet?
 
(...) OK, good. I understand that it would be some work and would like to see your time spent elsewhere as well. For example: (URL) much rather see this first. :) Ben Roller (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
In lugnet.admin.general, Todd Lehman writes: I think I've already said just about everything I have to say on this topic :) But if you're counting numbers... (...) I think being able to instantly see rated messages sitting next each other in a group (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: What should be done about ratings
 
(...) Good point. I see a growing need for a "ratings HOW-TO" page. (...) If just anyone can rate a message, what's to keep me from creating 100 accounts and rating my posts up to "100" for whatever reason? Todd's taking steps to verify existance of (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) help -- (...) to (...) clear (...) I think the rating system, in a ideal world, is a great idea. However, this is not an ideal world. The trouble with the system is, as I see it, that not enough members are voting - and those who are voting (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
Many of my posts have never received any replies or follow-ups, which is quite depressing. With the current scoring system, at least I know one or two people have read my post. This often makes me feel better. The actual score is not that important. (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)  
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) Just for the record.. it isn't me! As in I do rate in loc.uk, but not all of them, and not my own posts :) Richard (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general, lugnet.loc.uk)
 
  Re: Opinions wanted: article rating harmful? (was: New feature: Article rating)
 
(...) I think this is my preference. Furthermore, I think it'd be good if the current numerical scheme (while cool from a geek point of view) were reduced to two buttons: "This article is great" and "This article is off-topic". (...) I'm sorta (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general) ! 
 
  Re: LUGNET getting too complex?
 
(...) I imagine that when Todd gets around to making the web site able to keep track of which messages you've read, this feature will be available there too. But I don't think that's going to be available for a while. :( (This is one of many reasons (...) (27 years ago, 20-Apr-00, to lugnet.admin.general)

Next Page:  5 more | 10 more | 20 more
Redisplay Messages:  All | Compact

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR