To LUGNET HomepageTo LUGNET News HomepageTo LUGNET Guide Homepage
 Help on Searching
 
Post new message to lugnet.cad.devOpen lugnet.cad.dev in your NNTP NewsreaderTo LUGNET News Traffic PageSign In (Members)
 CAD / Development / 9672
9671  |  9673
Subject: 
[Parts Tracker] More name changes for Dishes
Newsgroups: 
lugnet.cad.dev
Date: 
Mon, 19 Apr 2004 15:24:15 GMT
Viewed: 
1573 times
  
[I'll follow-up this message with an FTX-formatted reference]

Here's some material for your Monday morning spit-take...

The following part files (mix of official and unofficial):
30209.dat     Plate  1 x  2 with  4 x  4 Disc at 90 Degrees
2654.dat      Boat  2 x  2 Stud
4740.dat      Dish  2 x  2
x902.dat      Cylinder  2 x  2 x  2/3 Dome Inverted
214.dat[1]    Dish  3 x  3
30065.dat     Round Dish  4 x  4
3960.dat      Dish  4 x  4
3960p02.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Black Spiral Pattern
3960p01.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Red & Green Petals Pattern
3960p04.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Blue and Red Stripes Pattern
3960p05.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Pink and Green Stripes Pattern
3960p03.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Red Spiral Pattern
3960p06.dat   Dish  4 x  4 with Red Stripes Pattern
6942.dat      Scala Cone  5 x  5
45729.dat     Dish  6 x  6
4285a.dat     Dish  6 x  6 Webbed - Type 1
4285a.dat     Dish  6 x  6 Webbed - Type 2
3961.dat      Round Dish  8 x  8
71874.dat     _Dish  2 x  2

are being renamed as follows:
30209.dat     Bracket  1 x  2 - Dish  4 x  4
2654.dat      Dish  2 x  2
4740.dat      Dish  2 x  2 Inverted
x902.dat      Dish  2 x  2 x   2/3 Hollow
214.dat       Dish  3 x  3 Inverted
30065.dat     Dish  4 x  4 Inverted
3960.dat      Dish  4 x  4 Inverted
3960p02.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Black Spiral Pattern
3960p04.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Blue and Red Stripes Pattern
3960p05.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Pink and Green Stripes Pattern
3960p03.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Red Spiral Pattern
3960p06.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Red Stripes Pattern
3960p01.dat   Dish  4 x  4 Inverted with Red and Green Petals Pattern
6942.dat      Dish  5 x  5
45729.dat     Dish  6 x  6 Inverted
4285a.dat     Dish  6 x  6 Inverted Webbed - Type 1
4285b.dat     Dish  6 x  6 Inverted Webbed - Type 2
3961.dat      Dish  8 x  8 Inverted
71874.dat     _Dish  2 x  2 Inverted

The history behind this change goes something like this:

Part 2654 (Boat 2 x 2 Stud) has had a Bad Name for a long time.  While
discussing options, Chris Dee suggested 'Plate 2 x 2 Dished'.  My first reaction
was 'ugh'.  However, in the course of writing a response, I looked up the
definition of 'dish', and looked at other 'dished' parts, and came to the
conclusion that part 2654 is really most like a dish.  Not a plate, not a tile,
but a dish.  I sent out a message that 2654 should be named 'Dish 2 x 2'.  I
received some rather strong negative responses.  I explained my position, and
did not receive any further response.  Maybe I convinced everyone; maybe I just
wore them down.

Furthermore, 2654 is a 'right side up' dish, and the radar dish parts should be
named as 'inverted dish' parts.  And other dish-like parts should be renamed to
be inline.

So that's where things stand.  Chris and I are agreed about this direction, and
I've submitted the changes to the Parts Tracker.  Further discussion towards
tweaking the names might be needed (for instance, vertical dimensionality is not
treated consistently) but the overall direction is pretty fixed at this point.

Feel free to flame.  I've donned my fire-retardant undies.

--
Steve
1) 214.dat should be an x-number, since it's not yet officially released.



Message has 1 Reply:
  Re: [Parts Tracker] More name changes for Dishes
 
List of parts affected by this latest dish-renaming. (URL) 30209.dat Bracket 1 x 2 - Dish 4 x 4 ((URL) PT Page>) (URL) 2654.dat Dish 2 x 2 ((URL) PT Page>) (URL) 4740.dat Dish 2 x 2 Inverted ((URL) PT Page>) (URL) x902.dat Dish 2 x 2 x 2/3 Hollow (...) (21 years ago, 19-Apr-04, to lugnet.cad.dev, FTX)

2 Messages in This Thread:

Entire Thread on One Page:
Nested:  All | Brief | Compact | Dots
Linear:  All | Brief | Compact
    

Custom Search

©2005 LUGNET. All rights reserved. - hosted by steinbruch.info GbR